Are you tired of chocolate peanut butter recipes yet? I sure hope not, because they are not going anywhere. We (and especially TheBetterHalf) are just way too obsessed with that flavor combo! We have Häagen-Dazs Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream in our freezer pretty much all the time. It is a dangerous habit.
I’ve had my eye on this cookie recipe for a long time now. I’ve seen them called Magic in the Middles, Chocolate Peanut Butter Surprise Cookies, Buckeye Cookies – whatever they are called, a chocolate cookie with peanut putter filling is pretty much pure heaven! First you make a basic chocolate cookie dough. Form it into balls and set it aside while you make the filling. Mix together peanut butter and powdered sugar, and form that into little balls as well. That stuff can be sticky! I used slightly damp hands when I was making the filling balls, and that worked well for me. Then you flatten out your cookie dough ball, place a peanut butter ball inside, shape the dough around the filling, and voila! I can see why people call them magic in the middles – you think it is just a simple chocolate cookie, but then you bite into it and there is sweet, peanut butter deliciousness! Magic some might say. Continue reading